Rings?

So, my boyfriend and I are approaching our 1 year anniversary!

It's hard to be sneaky since we live together, so i've been looking around etsy for something to get him.

He mentioned perhaps a ring.. but i'm a little weary of getting one for him. He's never bought me a ring, just a weird teddy bear necklace. haha.

I do love it, btw ;)

Here are some of the ideas i've come up with.

This one is from ZoeAndDoyle and can be anodized a solid color! I think i would get this in a green color, his favorite colors are black and green.

This one is from SilverGarden, and i really love the leaf pattern! I'm not sure how into it john would be though, he's so hard to shop for!

These rings might be exactly what i'm looking for though! They come in a pair, and are made from the same piece of metal and treated so they match as much as possible. They're amazing looking! They're from JSurine and are actually the cheapest option as well!

Let me know what you think! I just don't know what to get him. I'm horrible at gifts! I couldn't give him soap, because he's always used them all lol.